Detecting cancer at its earliest stages is critical, yet current diagnostic tools often lack the sensitivity needed for reliable results.
Traditional methods can miss subtle genetic and epigenetic signals present in cell-free DNA (cfDNA), slowing progress in biomarker discovery. A more refined approach is needed to capture these elusive markers.
This application note highlights how methylation sequencing and custom capture panels improve sensitivity and specificity, opening new possibilities for liquid biopsy research.
Download this application note to explore:
- How methylation sequencing enhances cfDNA analysis
- Ways custom panels focus sequencing on critical targets with greater precision
- Results from clinical research demonstrating improved early-stage sensitivity
Sequencing coverage of target regions using bisulfite- and enzyme-converted
libraries. Enzymatic conversion yields more even GC coverage than bisulfite
conversion.
Twist Methylation Detection System and
Custom Capture Panels Aid Research on
Early Cancer Detection
As a rule of thumb, the sooner a cancer is detected, the easier it is to treat. Therefore, developing tools for early cancer detection can
help save lives. In this effort, the capture and sequencing of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) has emerged as a promising source of diagnostic
information. Researchers are using custom target enrichment panels to extract and analyze DNA fragments shed from cancerous cells
and captured in blood samples—enabling the use of liquid biopsies for less invasive and more sensitive screening. Additionally, advances
in methylation sequencing workflows are improving cfDNA analysis by exposing epigenetic clues about the cancer’s subtype and tissue
of origin. Together, custom target enrichment panels and methylation sequencing give researchers tools to develop more sensitive and
specific early cancer detection assays.
TWIST METHYLATION DETECTION SYSTEM
Methylation is a repressive epigenetic mark on DNA that plays
an important role in defining cell identity. Importantly, during
transformation, cells undergo characteristic changes to their
methylome. Methylation sequencing can thus be used to both
identify malignant patterns and trace cfDNA to its tissue of origin.
Twist Bioscience has developed a new, highly sensitive
method for detecting methylation patterns in cfDNA that uses
enzymes—rather than bisulfite chemistry—to convert methylated
cytosine to uracil. Relative to traditional methylation sequencing
workflows, Twist’s methylation detection system reduces
damage to the DNA and enables up to 15% more methylation
detection within promoter CpG islands. To further increase the
efficiency of methylation sequencing, Twist also provides custom
target enrichment panels.
BISULFITE CONVERSION ENZYMATIC CONVERSION
TARGET READ COUNTS
GC CONTENT OF TARGET (%) GC CONTENT OF TARGET (%)
0
20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100
50
100
150
200
250
300
IMPROVING SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY
In a blinded, multicenter clinical trial, Lin et al.,2 evaluated
methylation sequencing of cfDNA as a component in early
detection of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The researchers
used a custom target enrichment panel (HelioLiver) synthesized
by Twist Bioscience to enrich for HCC cfDNA fragments in liquid
biopsies collected from 247 patients (122 with HCC). Enzymatic
methylation sequencing was then used to identify cfDNA
methylation patterns. This data was combined with demographic
data and results from a conventional immunoassay (targeting
HCC proteins) to determine if HCC was present.
Results show that the researchers’ use of target enrichment and
methylation sequencing in addition to conventional biomarker
analyses improved HCC detection sensitivity. Specifically, they
found sensitivity for stages I and II HCC to be 75.7%, well above
the 64.9% sensitivity of the current gold standard diagnostic
method (ultrasound using multiphasic MRI, GALAD). This is just
one example of how Twist’s custom target enrichment panels and
methylation sequencing workflow can support the research and
development of better diagnostic tools for early cancer detection.
Results from Lin et al.,2 comparing early cancer detection tools. The HelioLiver
test included a Twist custom target enrichment panel and methylation sequencing
which led to more sensitive HCC detection at stages I and II. For comparison, the
sensitivity of established HCC surveillance blood tests is shown. AFP = alpha fetal
protein. GALAD = score that incorporates Demographic and AFP measures SENSITIVITY
HelioLiver GALAD AFP
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
76.00%
65.00%
57.00%
TWIST BIOSCIENCE
These products are for research use only, and subject to additional use restrictions as set forth in Twist’s Supply Terms and Conditions: www.twistbioscience.com/supply-terms-and-conditions
DOC-001321 REV 1.0
REFERENCES
1. “Detecting Cancer’s Methylation Fingerprint in Blood Plasma | Twist Bioscience.” Www.twistbioscience.com, www.twistbioscience.com/resources/case-study/detecting-cancers-methylationfingerprint-blood-plasma.
2. Lin, Nan, et al. “A Multi-Analyte Cell-Free DNA-Based Blood Test for Early Detection of Hepatocellular Carcinoma.” Hepatology Communications, 3 Mar. 2022, 10.1002/hep4.1918.
Accessed 5 Apr. 2022.
TALK TO US ABOUT YOUR NEXT PROJECT.
Contact the Twist Bioscience team at support@twistbioscience.com or visit twistbioscience.com
CUSTOM TARGET CAPTURE
Rather than sequencing every bit of genetic material in a sample,
custom target capture panels help researchers focus sequencing
resources on just the targets of interest by hybridizing sample
DNA with a pool of biotinylated oligonucleotide probes. After
pulldown, the captured targets can then be sequenced.
Twist Bioscience synthesizes highly uniform, precise, and
customizable capture panels that can be leveraged for early
cancer detection research. According to Kristi Kruusmaa, Head of
Research at Universal DX, “Twist’s custom panel has enabled us
to achieve the enrichment level and precision that we need. When
we started with NGS for methylation detection, the maximum we
could target was 30 regions, but now with our Custom Panel from
Twist, we can capture thousands with better coverage.”1
When combined with methylation sequencing, custom panel
design can be challenging. The reduced complexity of DNA
fragments produced in methylation sequencing workflows can
make it hard to predict which probes you need in your panel.
In addition to panel synthesis, Twist has a team of panel design
experts who are available to help ensure your panel’s design is
optimized to fit your needs.
Twist Methylation Detection system detects hypo- and hypermethylated DNA
with high sensitivity. Shown here are results from an experiment using the Twist
Methylation Detection system and libraries of varying methylation levels (0–100%
methylation) in defined ratios.
30X COVERAGE (%) FOLD80 BASE PENALTY
PERCENT OFF BAIT (%) DUPLICATION RATE (%)
<5% 25% 50% 75% ~100%
0
20
40
60
80
100
1
1
10
20
30
40
50
60
1.25
1.5
1.75
2
2.25
1
1
2
3
4
5