We've updated our Privacy Policy to make it clearer how we use your personal data. We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. You can read our Cookie Policy here.

Advertisement

Upgrade Kit Makes 2D Mass Spectrometry Possible on Benchtop Instruments

A digital illustration of molecular structures floating around in empty space.
Credit: D koi / Unsplash.
Read time: 5 minutes

In a typical tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) workflow, chromatography is often used to isolate different analytes of interest, which are then sequentially fragmented, and a mass spectrum is recorded for the fragments associated with each precursor.


In two-dimensional mass spectrometry (2DMS), ions from the sample are held in an ion trap and subjected to a sequence of radio-frequency excitation steps. This frequency encoding step makes it possible to correlate precursor ions with their fragments, allowing for all fragments from all precursors to be measured simultaneously—reducing or even sometimes removing the need for chromatographic separation.


This makes 2DMS particularly interesting for complex mixtures and for samples where conventional separation is difficult or risks losing useful information. Historically, however, the technique has only been achievable with Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometers; these high-performance instruments are found only at specialized facilities, making 2DMS inaccessible to most.


Now, researchers at the University of Warwick and spin-out company Verdel Instruments have successfully designed an upgrade kit for use with benchtop quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-TOF) instruments, enabling them to perform 2DMS measurements. This method, which the team calls Q-2DMS, was detailed in a paper recently published in Analytical Chemistry.


To learn more about 2DMS, the performance of the upgrade kit, and the potential applications for this technology, Technology Networks spoke with Tim Wilson, CEO of Verdel Instruments. 

Alexander Beadle (AB):

Can you elaborate on the power of 2DMS as a technique, and why this type of analysis has been inaccessible to many labs? 


Tim Wilson (TW):

The real power of 2DMS is that it can preserve the relationship between precursor ions and their fragments without requiring each precursor to be isolated before fragmentation. In conventional MS/MS experiments, a single precursor molecule is selected and isolated, so that when it’s fragmented—using collision-induced dissociation (CID) or any of the other fragmentation techniques—you know that this collection of fragment molecules are all product ions of this single precursor. If you have multiple precursor ions in the spectrometer at the same time, you create a 'multi-jigsaw puzzle,' mixing the pieces from several jigsaws, and there’s no picture on the box to tell you which piece goes where. This produces what is known as a 'chimeric spectrum,' and it’s a common problem in conventional MS/MS experiments, especially in complex mixtures where complete separation is difficult.


Conventional workflows address that problem in two main ways. Liquid chromatography separates components in time, while quadrupole mass filters select ions within a defined mass-to-charge range before fragmentation. Both are extremely effective, but both depend on separating or selecting part of the sample before collecting the fragment-ion information.


Those are powerful techniques, but selection inevitably means that some information is lost. In some cases, you might not know what has been lost—and that could be critical. In others, the exclusion process itself can be problematic; intact proteins, for example, may not remain intact. In each case, you've lost some information before you've even started.


2DMS is a direct infusion technique. In some cases, sample prep or cleanup might still be needed, but in principle, you can take your sample and infuse the whole thing and still get usable data. That's the real power of it. It's not a panacea; it's not going to replace LC-MS/MS, but it is another tool in the analyst’s bag.


One way of thinking about 2DMS is that it allows you to discard less and discover more. But until recently, it was only practically possible on an FT-ICR instrument. Those are very expensive, need a room twice as big as the one I'm sitting in, with good supplies of liquid helium and liquid hydrogen, and you'll want some postdoc-level researchers to run it. Consequently, there just aren't that many FT-ICR MS instruments in the world. I read a piece somewhere that suggested there are approximately 400 installed, mostly at academic research institutions. We aim to make 2DMS functionality available on the benchtop Q-TOF instruments people already have in a standard lab.



AB:

A key component of this technology is the application of stored waveform ion radius modulation (SWIM) to ions trapped in the quadrupole prior to analysis in the mass analyzer. Could you expand on the SWIM technique and how this enables 2DMS to be performed in Q-TOF mass spectrometers? 


TW:

Broadly speaking, we take control of the instrument's quadrupole and operate it as an ion trap rather than only as a mass filter. By controlling the entrance and exit lenses, we can fill the trap with a broad mixture of ions from the sample. That data-independent starting point is important because we are not selecting only the most abundant or most obvious precursor ions before the experiment begins.


DDA vs DIA

Data-dependent acquisition (DDA): A mass spectrometry strategy where the instrument conducts an initial survey scan before selecting and fragmenting only specific precursor ions, usually those that are the most abundant. Often used for exploratory identification and profiling.

Data-independent acquisition (DIA): A mass spectrometry strategy in which all ions within pre-defined mass-to-charge (m/z) windows are systematically fragmented and analyzed. Useful in uncovering lower-abundance analytes missed in targeted analysis approaches.


SWIM uses carefully designed broadband radio-frequency waveforms to control the radial motion of ions in the trap. Each waveform contains multiple frequency components, and we vary their relative amplitudes across a sequence of excitation pulses. Different ions, therefore, experience characteristic patterns of excitation according to their mass-to-charge ratio. In some ways, it is conceptually similar to nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), but the physics is quite different.


We then couple that controlled ion motion to a fragmentation process that is sensitive to the ions' radial position. We’ve developed the technique using both UV photodissociation (UVPD) and collision-induced dissociation (CID)—which is typically the default fragmentation mechanism in MS/MS experiments. In UVPD, an ultraviolet laser is directed along the central axis of the quadrupole. Ions with greater radial excitation spend less time in the laser beam and therefore tend to fragment less; ions closer to the axis interact more strongly and tend to fragment more. This is reversed in CID, where the higher the excitation, the greater the collision energy and fragmentation increases.


The scans are assembled into a single experiment and processed using a Fourier transform. We look for modulation frequencies in the measured ion signals. As the fragmentation of a precursor population increases, its own signal tends to decrease while the signals from its fragments increase. Fragment ions that carry the corresponding modulation can therefore be associated with that precursor population. That relationship is what creates the second dimension in the final dataset.


In our recently published paper, we show Q-2DMS distinguishing a precursor population down to about one-tenth of a Dalton. This can be used to spread out a very complex chimeric spectrum with hundreds of precursors and thousands of fragments along a second dimension, where every slice will give a clean 1D mass spectrum of a single precursor in a single charge state, with all of its associated fragments.



AB:

How does this technique compare to other mass spectrometry approaches?


TW:

In project management, you often hear of the 'iron triangle'; the balance between cost, speed, and scope, where you can only pick two. In mass spectrometry, it is similar, but your variables are speed, sensitivity, and selectivity.


Q-2DMS prioritizes sensitivity and selectivity over speed. Today, a typical experiment takes 15–17 minutes, but that’s including all analytes. You wouldn’t dream of doing a targeted analysis on a Q-2DMS instrument, but it can be very useful for complex mixtures or dealing with unknowns. 



AB:

In terms of application areas, where exactly might such a 2DMS conversion kit be most useful?


TW:

We’re exploring four 'application spaces,' where the space is defined by how the technique might be valuable.


The first is about reducing the time spent on difficult chromatography. Oligos are an example here where the separation is challenging; mobile phases are complex such that, in some cases, entire LC-MS/MS instruments are devoted to a single method.


The second is about unknowns. PFAS in the environment, metabolomics, and degradation studies are all good examples where the analyst simply doesn’t know which analytes are in the sample. Drugs of abuse is another interesting example where the rapid evolution of synthetic opioids, such as nitazines, and other molecular types means there can be a new molecule in circulation every week, but you don't know exactly what it is. You want a method that can do a broad scan and look at everything, then rapidly identify unknowns.


Then there’s a category of experiments where the question isn’t 'what’s in this sample?' but 'how similar is this sample to these others?', i.e., classification problems. We recently did some work on black pepper with Queen's University Belfast. Black pepper is full of small, differentiated flavor molecules. We extracted and infused a set of samples where the country of origin was already known—with no separation, no clean-up—and used the data to build a classification model. The value comes from the fact that all analytes are included and it’s a direct infusion. That means more data points in the classification model and fewer external artifacts such as retention time, drift, etc. All the samples were correctly classified using simple statistical techniques.


And finally, we’re exploring the value of UVPD fragmentation, because Q-2DMS is particularly well-suited to it. UVPD is a photon-driven, rather than collision-driven, fragmentation process; it can produce fragment ions that aren’t seen using collision-based methods. Those additional fragments may be structurally diagnostic in specialist applications, such as lipid analysis, for example.



Google News Preferred Source Add Technology Networks as a preferred Google source to see more of our trusted coverage.