Substance abuse reduces brain volume in women but not men
News Jul 14, 2015
Stimulant drug abuse has long-term effects on brain volume in women, according to a new study published online in the journal Radiology. Brain structures involved in reward, learning and executive control showed vast changes even after a prolonged period of abstinence from drug use.
"We found that after an average of 13.5 months of abstinence, women who were previously dependent on stimulants had significantly less gray matter volume in several brain areas compared to healthy women," said the study's senior author, Jody Tanabe, M.D., professor of radiology, vice chair of Research, and Neuroradiology Section Chief at the University of Colorado Denver School of Medicine. "These brain areas are important for decision making, emotion, reward processing and habit formation."
T1-weighted MR imaging examination of the brain with superimposed population-level T-value map show significantly greater gray matter volume in female healthy control subjects than in women with substance dependence, after correction for age, brain size, and years of education. Credit: Radiological Society of North America
For the study, Dr. Tanabe and colleagues sought to determine how the brains of people previously dependent on stimulants differed from the brains of healthy people.
"We specifically wanted to determine how these brain effects differed by gender," Dr. Tanabe said.
The researchers analyzed structural brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) exams in 127 men and women, including 59 people (28 women and 31 men) who were previously dependent on cocaine, amphetamines, and/or methamphetamine for an average of 15.7 years, and 68 healthy people (28 women and 40 men) who were similar in age and gender. The MRI results showed that after an average of 13.5 months of abstinence, women who were previously dependent on stimulants had significantly less gray matter volume in frontal, limbic and temporal regions of the brain.
"While the women previously dependent on stimulants demonstrated widespread brain differences when compared to their healthy control counterparts, the men demonstrated no significant brain differences," Dr. Tanabe said.
T1-weighted MR imaging brain map (left) including coronal (top) and axial (bottom) section im¬ages shows significantly negative correlations at whole-brain level between stimulant dependence symptom count and gray matter volume in the bilateral nucleus accumbens in a patient with stimulant dependence. Scatterplot (right) shows negative correlation between substance dependence symptom count and total volume of nucleus accumbens defined according to region of interest. Credit: Radiological Society of North America
The researchers also looked at how these brain volume differences were related to behaviors. They found that lower regional gray matter volumes correlated with behavioral tendencies to seek reward and novelty.
"Lower gray matter volumes in women who had been stimulant dependent were associated with more impulsivity, greater behavioral approach to reward, and also more severe drug use," Dr. Tanabe said. "In contrast, all men and healthy women did not show such correlations."
Effects of sex on gray matter volume (GMV) according to group and behavior. Left, scatterplots show effect of group according to sex on correlation between approach and GMV in bi¬lateral middle frontal gyri (dorsolateral prefrontal cortex). Right, scatterplots show effect of group according to sex on correlation between impulsivity and GMV in left superior temporal gyrus and left insula. Middle, illustrations show clusters of whole-brain significant differences in group according to sex and impulsivity (red) and group according to sex and approach (green). BAS = Behavioral Activation System, BIS = Barratt Impulsiveness Scale, Ctrl = control subject, SDI = substance dependent individual. Credit: Radiological Society of North America
According to Dr. Tanabe, the results may provide a clue to the biological processes underlying the clinical course of stimulant abuse in men and women.
"Compared to men, women tend to begin cocaine or amphetamine use at an earlier age, show accelerated escalation of drug use, report more difficulty quitting and, upon seeking treatment, report using larger quantities of these drugs," she said. "We hope that our findings will lead to further investigation into gender differences in substance dependence and, thus, more effective treatments."
Note: Material may have been edited for length and content. For further information, please contact the cited source.
Tanabe J et al. Sex Differences in Gray Matter Changes and Brain-Behavior Relationships in Patients with Stimulant Dependence. Radiology, Published Online July 2015. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2015142541