In February 2015, the photo of a striped dress stirred a worldwide internet debate. Now, neuroscientists at the university clinic Bergmannsheil in Bochum have further decoded the phenomenon, demonstrating that the optical illusion is linked to specific brain activation patterns. The study results have been published in the journal Cortex.
MRT study on test subjects
One dress -- two perceptions. For some, it is black-blue, for others, it is white-gold. In a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) study, the neuroplasticity group headed by Prof. T. Schmidt-Wilcke solved the riddle of the illusion. In no time at all, the dress had captured the attention of media and scientists worldwide. Many renowned research institutes have explored the phenomenon from various angles, by analyzing the psychophysics or details of the image components. The Bochum researchers Lara Schlaffke, Lauren Haag and Anne Golisch now expanded the previous findings by providing insights into the differences in human brain activity caused by the contrasting perceptions.
No activation differences in color control condition
The Bochum study tested participants who perceived the dress as white-gold or black-blue, respectively. In an MRI scanner, brain activation of all participants was measured while they looked at the photo of The Dress via a computer-based presentation system. In the control condition, participants looked at colored squares with the same color properties as the photo of The Dress. In this control condition, no differences between the groups were identified in correctly naming the colors of the squares, nor in brain activation during the presentation of the colored squares.
The dress activates frontal and parietal brain areas
Subsequently, the researchers analyzed the brain activation in both groups during presentation of The Dress. They demonstrated that in a direct comparison of groups the photo triggered differential brain activation, depending on their perception. All participants who saw the dress as white-gold presented additional activation, mainly in frontal and parietal brain areas. Frontal regions are particularly involved in higher cognitive processes such as selective attention and decision making, while parietal areas process visual information from the occipital lobe.
Unique research approach
The phenomenon of The Dress provides a unique approach to researching visual illusions: for the first time, scientists had the opportunity to study a control group in a case of ambiguous perception. Before, no optical illusion existed with exactly two competing perceptions which could not be deliberately manipulated. By means of this phenomenon, the Bergmannsheil research group succeeded in identifying brain areas which cause optical illusions. "These results expand our knowledge of illusion processing in the brain. Based on the research findings, we were able to quantify the brain areas involved in the process, thus we have laid a foundation for further research in the field of visual processing," conclude the successful women researchers, who otherwise deal with dresses in a different context.
Note: Material may have been edited for length and content. For further information, please contact the cited source.
Tegenthoff M et al. The Brain’s Dress Code: How The Dress allows to decode the neuronal pathway of an optical illusion. Cortex, Published Online September 30 2015. doi: 10.1016/j.cortex.2015.08.017