Man with restored sight provides new insight into how vision develops
News Apr 15, 2015
California man Mike May made international headlines in 2000 when his sight was restored by a pioneering stem cell procedure after 40 years of blindness.
But a study published three years after the operation found that the then-49-year-old could see colors, motion and some simple two-dimensional shapes, but was incapable of more complex visual processing.
Hoping May might eventually regain those visual skills, University of Washington (UW) researchers and colleagues retested him a decade later. But in a paper now available online in Psychological Science, they report that May -- referred to in the study as M.M. -- continues to perform significantly worse than sighted control group participants.
The conclusion: May's vision remains very limited 15 years after the surgeries. Though disappointing, the results provide valuable information that can help researchers better understand how vision develops and which visual processing tasks are most vulnerable to sight deprivation.
"With sight-restoration procedures becoming more developed, we're going to see more and more cases where people are blind for long periods of time and then get their sight back," said senior author Ione Fine, a UW associate professor of psychology.
"But we know very little about what happens in their brains during that period. That is going to be one of the fundamental questions going forward -- what happens when the lights are turned off, and what happens when you turn them back on?"
May went blind at age 3 when a jar of chemicals exploded in his face. He went on to work for the CIA and became a successful entrepreneur, founding the Sendero Group, a company that makes GPS and talking-map products for blind people. May is also a motivational speaker and holds the world downhill skiing speed record, 65 mph, for a completely blind person.
But fully restored sight has eluded May, and his unusual case has puzzled researchers. There were few previous cases of restored vision before his -- the last well-documented one was in 1963 -- and scientists knew little about whether people whose sight is restored as adults can regain functional vision, and if so, how long that might take.
In the recent tests, May was shown images of household objects and faces, and also video clips while his brain responses were measured with fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging). As with the tests a decade earlier, May did not have normal brain responses to three-dimensional objects or faces, consistent with his inability to make sense of these stimuli.
Researchers believe that's because May's brain, like those of other people who went blind at an early age, has adjusted to respond to other stimuli, such as sound or touch.
"We suspect that Mike lost vision at an age when these brain regions were able to take on new roles," said joint first author Jason Webster. "It remains to be seen what these areas are doing now."
May's case is particularly interesting, Fine said, because his blindness started when the visual system is already developed, but the ability to perceive objects and faces is still evolving.
"He lost his vision at an age when vision is pretty good, but he was still young enough for it to deteriorate," she said.
The findings, the researchers say, indicate that visual function for tasks such as object recognition and face processing continues to develop through childhood and early adolescence and remains sensitive to loss of sight for several years afterward.
The good news, said joint first author and UW graduate student Elizabeth Huber, is that the findings imply that adults' vision is relatively fixed, meaning that as visual losses increase in an aging population, the chances of restoring useful sight to older people are good.
"This study is encouraging because it suggests that if someone loses sight later in life, it may still be possible to restore relatively normal vision, even after many years of blindness," she said.
May told the researchers he uses his other senses to compensate for his poor vision.
"I have learned what works with vision and what doesn't, so I really don't challenge my vision much anymore," he said in the paper. "Where motion or colors might be clues, I use my vision. Where details might be required, like reading print or recognizing who someone is, I use tactile and auditory techniques."
Note: Material may have been edited for length and content. For further information, please contact the cited source.
E. Huber, J.M. Webster, A.A. Brewer, D.I.A. MacLeod, B.A. Wandell, G.M. Boynton, A.R. Wade, I. Fine. A Lack of Experience-Dependent Plasticity After More Than a Decade of Recovered Sight. Psychological Science, Published April 2015. doi: 10.1177/0956797614563957
Some of the most advanced tools in neuroscience are developed for use with mice, yet studies of behaviors most relevant to humans typically involve other model organisms. Anne Churchland and colleagues addressed this gap by investigating the mouse's potential as an animal model of decision-making.READ MORE
When MIT neuroscientist Earl Miller was in graduate school at Princeton, he was inspired by the lectures of George A. Miller, an influential psychologist who helped to spark the young student’s interest in working memory. Now, as the newly named 2019 recipient of the George A. Miller Prize in Cognitive Neuroscience, Earl Miller is set to deliver a lecture honoring his teacher.READ MORE