The Hunt for Therapeutic Antibodies
The Hunt for Therapeutic Antibodies
A brief history of antibodies: the “magic bullets”
The potential benefits of antibodies have long been recognized. In 1890, Emil von Behring (Germany) and Shibasabura Kitasato (Japan) showed that injections of serum from an animal with tetanus could confer immunity to the disease in other animals.1 Behring was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1901, following the realization of the potential implications of this concept for human health.
Behring also collaborated with Paul Ehrlich, who understood that antibodies in the blood had some level of specificity and imagined that they acted as “magic bullets” fired from a gun to hit specific targets, while leaving host tissue in peace.2
In 1975, Köhler & Milstein published a paper in Nature3 describing the development of tissue culture cell lines which secrete anti-sheep red blood cell antibodies. This work signified the beginning of the modern era of antibody research and discovery.
Fast-forward to 2019Hopefully, Behring, Ehrlich and the like would be proud of the legacy they have left. Antibodies have found their place as an integral part of three main areas of medicine:
- Research – antibodies facilitate the measurement of hormones under investigation, e.g. in radioimmunoassays
- Diagnostics – specific antibodies can be measured to indicate the presence of a pathogen, or to confirm a suspected allergy. Antibodies also facilitate the measurement of other biomarkers.
- Therapeutics – a successful therapeutic antibody will bind with high specificity to the target protein (antigen) and suppress or stimulate downstream effects. The mechanism through which antibodies elicit their effect varies. Antibodies can inhibit ligand binding by blocking the receptor or ligand, binding to cell surface proteins and tagging the cell for binding by cytotoxic T cells (such as in cancer), or by causing receptors to be internalized and therefore, downregulated.
Given the clinical success that these “magic bullets” have facilitated, the drug discovery field continues to search for new therapeutic candidates.
Accelerating Antibody Development with Automated Octet Assays [Whitepaper]
Drug development and production is challenging, however, high throughput characterization systems can greatly accelerate discovery programs.
Download this whitepaper to discover the key considerations for automated Octet assays.View Whitepaper
There is no “magic bullet technique” for finding the next “magic bullet”There is a whole host of techniques that can aid the process of identifying which antibodies would be suitable therapeutic candidates. However, deciding on a technique is never “black and white” – it depends on the question you’re asking. Furthermore, selecting new antibodies can be a very time- and labor-intensive process with uncertain chances of success. While the development and production of monoclonal antibodies is driven by biotech companies and pharmaceutical firms, the fundamental scientific basis for such development typically originates in academia, where the budgets don’t stretch so far.
One person helping to bridge the gap between academia and industry is David Matthews, associate director of Biotherapeutics at LifeArc. LifeArc is a charity that works with academic researchers to develop projects which show potential for translation from the bench to the clinic. As David is involved in antibody generation, humanization, affinity maturation and the biochemical characterization of candidates, he is very familiar with the complexity of the process.
According to David, some of the most widely techniques used in the field are:
- Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is a technique particularly useful for hybridoma production (see grey box for a definition). To generate a hybridoma, a host would be immunized with the antigen that the antibody of interest (AOI) recognizes. ELISAs are used to confirm the presence of the AOI in the blood, after which multiple booster immunizations are administered to amplify antibody production.
- SPR (surface plasma resonance) – an optical technique used to assess biomolecular interactions between two or molecules, such as antibody-antigen affinity.
- Flow cytometry – a powerful, high-content analysis technique which enables the user to screen multiple parameters at the same time, and selects antibodies that bind the protein of interest.4
Antigen: Antigens (antibody generator) generate an immune response, and bind to specific antibodies. Antigens can be toxic foreign substances or “self antigens” perceived to be foreign, which trigger autoimmunity.
Interdisciplinary collaboration is driving the next generation of antibody discovery platforms
“Our 2018 paper describes bioinformatics analysis, based on documented studies, of conserved epitope residues of HCV glycoproteins that are targets of a wide panel of antibodies (isolated by several research groups) that are capable of neutralizing diverse strains of HCV (the so called broadly neutralizing antibodies). This analysis identified several antibodies which could represent a starting point for developing broadly neutralizing antibody-based vaccines.”
Streamlining the Antibody Discovery Workflow at ModiQuest Research [App Note]
Therapeutic antibody discovery is a competitive landscape that requires high throughput tools enabling large screening campaigns and software capable of easily analyzing large multiplexed data sets. Current antibody screening tools such as ELISA, only report on binding to one target antigen at a time hence they are time consuming and require large amounts of target protein.
Learn how scientists at ModiQuest Research significantly reduced their lead discovery time while conserving valuable samples and cutting down reagent cost.
Exact mechanism of action can be determined after antibody identificationInterestingly, sometimes knowledge of the mechanism behind protection comes after the identification of a highly effective antibody. For example, a potent antibody combination was identified as being highly effective in the treatment of Chikungunya virus in mice.6 Chikungunya virus is a mosquito-transmitted disease that causes global epidemics of polyarthritis in humans. Michael Diamond, Professor in the Departments of Medicine, Molecular Microbiology, Pathology & Immunology at the Washington University School of Medicine was integral to this study, and described the process of identifying the antibody combination, CHK-152 and CHK-166:
“We immunized mice, identified mAbs that bound virus-infected cells, and then tested them for neutralizing activity in vitro and therapeutic activity in vivo. It was labor-intensive and took about a year.”
Only recently has the mechanism behind the antibody efficacy became clearer. Antibody engineering in conjunction with mouse strains lacking certain antibody-binding receptors revealed a central role of Fcγ receptors on monocytes in driving the therapeutic effects.7 According to Diamond, this has implications for the development of other vaccines, such as influenza, HIV, and Ebola.
“This will likely be important for many viruses that display their viral proteins on the surface of infected cells and can be targets of antibodies and their effector functions.”
The hunt for therapeutic antibodies isn’t a linear taskThe process of hunting for therapeutic antibodies can look very different from lab to lab. As antibody candidates must contain many desirable characteristics, it takes a combination of techniques and platforms to assess them.
Regardless of the approaches selected, each are bound to benefit from common trends such as the integration of different disciplines, machine learning and increased automation of assay setups.
- Behring, E., and Kitasato, S. (1890). Uber das Zustandekommen Der Diphtherie- Immunitat Und der Tetanus-Immunitat Bei Thieren. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 49, 1113–1114.
- Winau, F., Westphal, O., & Winau, R. (2004). Paul Ehrlich — in search of the magic bullet. Microbes and Infection, 6(8), 786-789. doi:10.1016/j.micinf.2004.04.003
- Köhler, G., & Milstein, C. (1975). Continuous cultures of fused cells secreting antibody of predefined specificity. Nature, 256(5517), 495-497. doi:10.1038/256495a0
- Bowen, W. (2010). High-throughput antibody screening using high-sensitivity microplate cytometry. Nature Methods, 7(12), 8-9. doi:10.1038/nmeth.f.320
- Cowton, V. M., Singer, J. B., Gifford, R. J., & Patel, A. H. (2018). Predicting the Effectiveness of Hepatitis C Virus Neutralizing Antibodies by Bioinformatic Analysis of Conserved Epitope Residues Using Public Sequence Data. Frontiers in Immunology, 9. doi:10.3389/fimmu.2018.01470
- Pal, P., Dowd, K. A., Brien, J. D., Edeling, M. A., Gorlatov, S., Johnson, S., . . . Diamond, M. S. (2013). Development of a Highly Protective Combination Monoclonal Antibody Therapy against Chikungunya Virus. PLoS Pathogens, 9(4). doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1003312
- Fox, J. M., Roy, V., Gunn, B. M., Huang, L., Edeling, M. A., Mack, M., . . . Diamond, M. S. (2019). Optimal therapeutic activity of monoclonal antibodies against chikungunya virus requires Fc-FcγR interaction on monocytes. Science Immunology, 4(32). doi:10.1126/sciimmunol.aav5062