The McGurk Effect- When What You See Overrides What You Hear
Seeing is not always believing – visual speech (mouth movements) mismatched with auditory speech (sounds) can result in the perception of an entirely different message. This mysterious illusion is known as the McGurk effect. Neuroscience researchers at Baylor College of Medicine have created an algorithm to reveal key insight into why the brain can sometimes muddle up one of the most fundamental aspects of the human experience.
The findings, appearing in the latest edition of PLOS Computational Biology, will be useful in understanding patients with speech perception deficits and in building computers able to understand auditory and visual speech.
“All humans grow up listening to tens of thousands of speech examples, with the result that our brains contain a comprehensive mapping of the likelihood that any given pair of mouth movements and speech sounds go together,” said Dr. Michael Beauchamp, professor of neuroscience at Baylor and co-author on the paper with John Magnotti, postdoctoral research fellow at Baylor. “In everyday situations we are frequently confronted with multiple talkers emitting auditory and visual speech cues, and the brain must decide whether or not to integrate a particular combination of voice and face.”
“Even though our senses are constantly bombarded with information, our brain effortlessly selects the verbal and nonverbal speech of our conversation partners from this cacophony,” Magnotti said.
The McGurk effect is an example of when this goes wrong. It happens when mouth movements that are seen can override what is heard, causing a person to perceive a different sound than what is actually being said. Only when the eyes are closed, and when the sound is being heard, can the correct message be perceived. For example, the visual “ga” combined with the auditory “ba” results in the perception of “da.”
Magnotti and Beauchamp were able to create an algorithm model of multisensory speech perception based on the principle of causal inference, which means given a particular pair of auditory and visual syllables, the brain calculates the likelihood they are from single versus multiple talkers and uses this likelihood to determine the final speech perception.
“We compared our model with an alternative model that is identical, except that it always integrates the available cues, meaning there is no casual inference of speech perception,” said Beauchamp, who also is director of the Core for Advanced MRI at Baylor. “Using data from a large number of subjects, the model with causal inference better predicted how humans would or would not integrate audiovisual speech syllables.”
“The results suggest a fundamental role for a causal inference type calculation going on in the brain during multisensory speech perception,” Magnotti said.
Researchers already have an idea of how and where the brain separately encodes auditory speech and visual speech, but this algorithm shines light on the process of how they are integrated. It will serve as a guide, highlighting specific brain regions that will be essential for multisensory speech perception.
"Understanding how the brain combines information from multiple senses will provide insight into ways to improve declines in speech perception due to typical aging and even to develop devices that could enhance hearing across the life span,” Beauchamp said.
This article has been republished from materials provided by Baylor College of Medicine. Note: material may have been edited for length and content. For further information, please contact the cited source.
New Data and Analysis Tools Released for Allen Brain ObservatoryNews
Allen Institute for Brain Science releases new data and analysis tools for the Allen Brain Observatory.READ MORE
Leading Charity Calls for Government to Confirm Plans for Dementia ResearchNews
Alzheimer's Research UK, the UK’s leading dementia research charity, has called for the new government to renew its commitment to funding research into the condition.READ MORE
Novel Imaging Method Reveals New Food-Seeking CircuitryNews
Researchers from the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center used a novel micro-periscope to investigate cell activity in the insular cortex during food seeking behaviour, revealing new neuronal pathways important for energy balance.READ MORE